Shopping Actions Program Drawbacks
While Google Shopping Actions may look like the perfect opportunity at first glance, there are certain aspects of the program that retailers might consider to be substantial drawbacks:
1. Decreased profit on low-margin products:
while cost-per-sale model gives retailers the comfort of not having to pay for a click that doesn’t always result in a purchase, the commission Google charges per sale may significantly deplete the profits on products sold.
Depending on the category it ranges between 5% and 15% - averaging 12% commission.
2. The risk of driving down the sales from regular Shopping and Search:
with the new program taking spots on Google’s ad surfaces it wouldn't be unreasonable to assume that a click going to Shopping Actions ad is one that previously would have likely been received by a traditional Google Shopping advertisement.
While the reality is not as black and white - it’s definitely a factor that may lead to decreasing merchants’ revenue from Shopping and Search.
3. Lack of a direct relationship with a Customer:
while Google making the entire shopping experience easier, faster and more consumer-friendly with its Shopping Actions marketplace is a benefit for all parties, ultimately it is Google who the customer goes into direct interaction with when making the purchase - not the retailer participating in the program.
This might mean missing out on some unique opportunities to engage with and build a lifetime relationship with your customers.
Machine Learning
With any ads on Google, they key aim is always relevancy. It constantly pushes to ensure relevancy of the ad to the customer and to the search enquiry.
Google’s foremost consideration is customer-side, they like to make everything as quick and easy for the customer as possible by answering the question or query with the most useful answer as possible. This is why there are measures to ensure your ads are relevant to the keyword/voice search term.
To aid the helpful experience on Shopping Actions, Google have (unsurprisingly) got an algorithm that is continually machine learning. As a retailer, it’s worth leveraging this machine learning for your own benefit.
Part of the machine learning identifies what the customer has previously purchased (or is currently looking at) and offers further complementary items.
For example, if you search for laptops, you may see additional products such as laptop bags, anti-virus software packs and accessories.
This can help with common upsells, effectively boosting basket sizes and order values as well as making the process easier for customers (they don’t need to make a second purchase when they realise they need a laptop bag or mouse, for example).
Getting on the program
If you’re not already set up with Google Shopping, you will need to set this up prior to opting in to Shopping Actions. You will need two plaforms to do this:
- Merchant Center: This is where your feed lives and is managed. Click here to get stared. The information provided here feeds into…
- Shopping Campaigns: To run Shopping ads, you will need to create your ads in the AdWords platform. From here you can import the feed information, optimise the ads and campaigns and manage click costs and budgets. You will need to go to the Google Ads set up page to begin.
Once you’re all set with the above, there are a few steps left to get into the Shopping Actions Program:
- You will first need to fill out a form by Google for Retail to express your interest in joining the program.
- Once approved, you will need to accept the terms & conditions in the Shopping Actions Tab of your Google Merchant Center account, along with finalizing the settings
- Once completed, request validation from your GMC account and you will be notified by Google once you receive the approval.
Shopping Actions Program Standards for Retailers
Shopping Actions Program is open to all types of retailers large and small, in the US and France. To be a top Shopping Actions retailer, there are a number of factors Google will take into account, this is measured using ‘retailer standards’.
Retailer standards are designed to measure your success as a retailer as well as identifying areas of improvement. You get a rating on a monthly basis based on performance over the last 90 days. To view your rating, simply head over to the Merchant Center and go to the Standards dashboard.
Source: Google Shopping Actions Performance Metrics
To determine your standards, the evaluation criteria looks at a number of factors; the primary factor being you defect rate’ which includes unfulfilled product and 1-star ratings.
Also check: Earn Shoppers Trust with Google Product Ratings
To be a top retailer, your defect rate needs to be less than 2%, meeting standards is 2-10% and any retailer with a defect rate above 10% will be considered ‘below standards’. There is currently no penalty for being in the ‘below standards’ category but Google has hinted this may change in future.
To be part of the ‘top retailer’ status you will also need to meet a further two standards, including:
- 300+ Orders: Over the last 90 days you need to have had over 300 orders or more.
- $15,000 in sales: Your total sales over the last 90 days need to be $15,000 USD or more.
Even if you meet the above criteria, you must still ensure you have a defect rate below 2%.
Shopping Actions - Feed Requirements
Base Feed:
Once you’ve joined the Google Shopping Actions program and completed the final validation, all you need on the feed side is your regular Google Shopping Feed, connected in your Google Merchant Account.
If you’re already using a feed for Google Shopping, you can continue to do so, and all products included in the feed will be opted-in to Shopping Actions as a default.
In case you decided to only utilize the marketplace option for selected products, you can use the ‘excluded_destination’ feed attribute. By selecting ‘Shopping Actions’ within that attribute, you are indicating which items should not be available for purchase through Shopping Actions.
Supplemental information:
Shopping Actions feed has several optional attibutes that traditional Shopping feed doesn’t contain. Those attributes allow you to submit additional information specifically related to the Shopping Actions listings, such as the number of products available to sell on Google, maximum order amount and more.
Here’s a full list of optional attributes.
In DataFeedWatch you may add those attributes by generating the feed based on our ‘Google Shopping Actions’ template. Once ready, you simply link it as a supplemental feed in your Google Merchant Center account.
Is Google Shopping Actions Right For Me?
Is your customer base right for Shopping Actions? Some might argue that if your target audience have the tendency to purchase in-store rather than online, Shopping Actions may not be for you.
However, being on the program and being available for your customers isn’t exactly bad practice.
It could be beneficial to be present to all pockets of customers wherever they are – even in smaller quantities. It’s also particularly useful if your products are sold through a larger third-party, for example Target.
Target have seen a lot of use in leveraging Google Shopping Actions. It comes on the back of a long standing partnership between themselves and Google and they were one of the first to test Google Express and now Shopping Actions.
They have since seen an increase in new markets, an increase in new users and according to Google, they’ve also seen nearly 20% increase in baskets on Express.
Other retailers who have jumped on the program in its infancy include Costco, Ulta and Home Depot.
Each of these have seen a great response, including their basket size increase by an average of 30% and an increase in conversions for less cost (compared with running just shopping ads alone).
Finally…
Regardless of whether or not Google Shopping Actions really does rival Amazon, retailers with customers who usually purchase online are highly likely to see a positive impact from streamlining the purchase process as well as appearing across multiple platforms and devices.
Not convinced? The only way you’ll know what does and does not work is trialling. Opting in could reward you with the possibility of increased sales.
If not, it’s still best practice to keep up to date with all eCommerce options to understand what works best for your store.